October Theme: The Unknown
Big Question: Why are we drawn to mystery and uncertainty?
Week 1: Mystery
👋Welcome to our first dialogue in October. I’m so glad you’re here!
This month, our drafts and dialogues will be centered around the theme, The Unknown. And throughout the month, we’ll be exploring drafts and dialogues and books that are centered on one main question: Why are we drawn to mystery and uncertainty?
To kickstart the month, we’re exploring Mystery, focusing on how a little bit of suspense and intrigue go a long way to not only grab our attention but keep us hooked and invested in a story, often long after we finish it. And through such explorations we might gain a better understanding of how to leverage it in our own drafts and writing processes as well, especially when we’re uncertain of what comes next.
Yet this exploration does first beg the question of whether mystery is always desirable or needed in storytelling, and whether it ultimately crafts ‘the better story’, even and especially when we aren’t writing actual mysteries full of clues detectives are chasing. Which brings us to today’s question: Does mystery drive a better story than predictability?
But this question, as per usual, only leads to more questions worth exploring this week, such as: Are there times when predictability, an assumed opposite of mystery, can craft a better story? And if so, when and how? Or are there certain genres and forms of writing that demand elements of mystery in them, while others demand predictability? Or should a degree of mystery be embedded into everything we write to keep readers engaged and reading, regardless of what we’re writing?
Wherever our questions lead us this week, I hope the dialogues they stimulate eventually allow us to view mystery as less of a mystery in our own writing, and that they allow us to intentionally decide when, where, why, and how we should use and include it in our own drafts. Essentially, I hope our dialogues allow us to approach and investigate mystery as more of an intentional craft choice and tool to leverage on a broader spectrum within our writing practice than as only something some writers use some of the time when they are writing literal mysteries. But I’m still curious and open to seeing where our conversations take us.
To get this dialogue started, please take a moment to participate in today’s poll, then take an additional moment to consider today’s question and the different responses to it drafted below.
As you consider the information in the responses to the dialogue drafted below, please encourage yourself to keep an open mind and adopt an attitude of genuine curiosity rather than predetermined judgment. This will allow more meaningful discussions to occur, as today’s question is intended to spark meaningful dialogue meant to improve our writing and creative lives rather than heated debate that’s draining and unproductive.
Next, let us know more about what you think in this month’s Dialoguers Chat as you continue to reflect.
As always, remember that there are no strict ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ answers, only those answers that will help us more authentically navigate this dialogue and ourselves as creators and writers and readers.
Regardless of what your initial answer or instinct is when responding to today’s question, I hope it spurs some much-needed reflection and discussion regarding how we navigate not only our craft but private lives as creators and writers and readers. And I can’t wait to see what you contribute!
Cast your vote, then keep reading. You may find yourself agreeing with one answer at first then challenging it later, after you engage in reflection and dialogue.
Drafting this Dialogue: Mystery vs Predictability in Storytelling
Yes, mystery drives a better story than predictability.
A powerful and engaging narrative thrives on the unknown, compelling readers to keep turning pages as they search for answers to the questions or mysteries initially presented. When a story contains secrets or unknown elements, or reveals them slowly, one at a time, it is more likely to actively engage its audience’s imagination and allow them to become more emotionally invested in it. Embedding mystery into a narrative essentially transforms passive consumers or readers into active participants who become increasingly eager to uncover the hidden or unknown elements behind the initial story or stories presented to them.
If you agree with this answer, you will probably also agree with one or more of the following statements:
Audiences naturally crave the intellectual challenge of solving a narrative puzzle.
Predictable plots reduce the emotional impact of breakthroughs that a story’s characters experience.
Suspense is a more effective tool for keeping a reader engaged than comfort.
The best stories are those that surprise us by breaking conventional tropes.
Unanswered questions in a story linger in the mind much longer than tidy endings.
To engage in further dialogue, ask:
Where do we draw the line between an engaging mystery and a frustrating or confusing plot?
Can a story rely too heavily on plot twists, at the expense of its characters’ development?
How does a writer successfully balance suspense and foreshadowing without giving away the ending?
Sometimes mystery drives a better story than predictability.
A story’s ideal narrative structure depends on its specific genre and its author’s goals or intentions. While a thriller typically requires a lot of suspense to function successfully, for example, a comforting romance or classic tragedy might rely more heavily on assuming that the reader will know, or might want to know (to some degree), what will happen next. And balancing these two forces allows a writer to deliver both excitement and emotional satisfaction. Furthermore, successful mysteries often require a baseline of predictability too, as a good mystery only works because the world within it behaves predictably to some degree. If gravity randomly stopped working or characters didn’t have typical human traits such as skepticism or greed or envy or they changed identities with no reasonable logic, the ‘mystery’ could dissolve into meaningless chaos or become dull and unrealistic. A mystery, in other words, is compelling precisely because it breaks an expected human-oriented pattern that needs to be established first.
If you agree with this answer, you will probably also agree with one or more of the following statements:
Certain genres require a high degree of predictability to satisfy their audiences’ expectations.
The relatable journey of a character is often far more important than an uncertain conclusion.
Masterful writers use predictability to build a false sense of security before introducing a twist.
A story needs a stable framework of predictable rules, so the mystery feels earned.
Total unpredictability can alienate an audience if they lose their sense of connection to the plot.
To engage in further dialogue, ask:
Which specific genres benefit the most from a predictable narrative structure?
How can an author use things like dramatic irony to make a predictable plot feel more thrilling?
What strategies help strike the perfect balance between comfort and uncertainty in fiction?
No, mystery does not drive a better story than predictability.
True satisfaction comes from the careful execution of a well-established promise in a narrative rather than unnecessary suspense or a bombardment of surprises and twists or red herrings. When an audience can anticipate where a story is going, even if they don’t have all the specific information yet, they’ll be better equipped to fully appreciate the depth of the narrative’s themes and plot, as well as the nuance of its characters’ personal evolutions and performances. Emotional and relatable predictability essentially provide a grounded structure that allows true understanding, reader engagement, and deep resonance to occur.
If you agree with this answer, you will probably also agree with one or more of the following statements:
Readers find immense comfort and satisfaction in seeing their expectations fulfilled.
Shock value or suspense is a temporary thrill that rarely holds up during a second reading.
Tragic stories gain their immense power from the audience’s dread of an inevitable conclusion.
Clear storytelling with relatable or compelling characters is always superior to a complex plot that relies solely on withholding information.
Consistent characters are far more valuable than a sudden twist or lingering suspense that disrupts or unnecessarily prolongs the narrative logic of a story.
To engage in further dialogue, ask:
Why do audiences love rewatching or rereading stories when they already know exactly how they end?
How does predictability enhance the thematic depth of historical fiction or myth retellings?
In what ways can a writer make a predictable plot feel unique and memorable without relying solely on suspense or mystery?
Join this Dialogue
This dialogue allows us to discuss how mystery and predictability influence our connection to a story, whether we’re the ones reading it or writing it. It also allows us to explore how, when, and why The Unknown might spark our curiosity rather than dissuade it, and whether there might be different genres or stories that call for a unique blend of predictability and mystery.
Instead of searching for the ‘right’ answer, however, let’s take a closer look at what makes a narrative feel compelling and satisfying as we engage in this dialogue, and allow ourselves to consider our own reading habits and what truly keeps us engaged too, whether it’s the excitement of an unsolved puzzle or the satisfaction of a beautifully executed journey.
If you’re interested in diving deeper into this topic, join the conversation in the Dialoguers Chat! It’s a space where curious minds like ours can gather to explore complex ideas like this, challenge our assumptions, and listen to diverse viewpoints in an open and respectful environment.
Whether you firmly believe mystery or predictability is key to a compelling story, your voice is a welcome addition to our community. Come connect with fellow writers, readers, and thinkers as we unpack how to understand the ways mystery operates in all the things we read and write.
P.S. You don’t have to fully commit to any of the responses when you join this dialogue. Just let us know whatever thoughts and feelings arise as you contemplate today’s question and use that to spur further discussion. There are no strict ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ answers here, just those authentic responses that will help us further explore this topic together.
Thanks again for being here and exploring this topic with us as we continue to discuss The Unknown this week.
I hope to see you in the comments or chat replies soon!
Please like and share this post with others so we can keep this dialogue going. ✨🗣️✨
Continue Exploring October’s Theme, The Unknown
Writing Prompts That Stir Up Mysteries
ICYM September’s Posts about The Stories We Carry
Popular Posts
Writing Prompts for Stories That Last
Drafting Diaries: The Stories We Carry
Drafting & Dialoguing Digest: The Stories We Carry
Writing Prompts About The Stories We Tell Others
The ‘Death of the Author’ in the Age of AI
Reading Notes: Interior Chinatown
The Story of My Flaws Sounds Like Death Metal
Historical Fiction that Challenges the Stories We Tell Ourselves
The Art of Autofiction: Memory, Markets, and the Modern Confessional
Writing Prompts About Books That Changed Us
What My Favorite Books Say About Me